Generally water leaks and poor ventilation leading to condensation are the main roof defects which give rise to a variety of fungi moulds and insect attacks.
Fungus on roof rafters.
Attic mold is often caused by warm moist air from the house leaking into the attic space.
Below are a few ways to check for possible roof leaks.
This causes condensation to form on the cold surfaces in the attic especially roof rafters sheathing and trusses.
I am planning on doing the repairs myself.
Fungal spores hyphae and conidiophores the spore producing structures of mold.
The name dry rot is a complete misnomer as all rot requires elevated quantities of moisture.
Re roofing with lining lining papers sarking roofing felt can cause severe mold growth and rot due to reduced ventilation.
Seal any openings like vents and windows using plastic sheeting.
In short no.
Wood rotting from the inside out compromises the structural integrity of the rafter.
The roof deck appears to be 1 x 6 boards maybe pine.
Testing attic mold in most cases testing for attic mold is unnecessary.
Even if conditions are conducive to mold growth elevated moisture plywood made from a fungal resistant wood will resist mold growth for quite a while.
I am wondering what would be the best replacement material.
These are distinct from molds and are relatively small in number in comparison to molds.
With your attic contained you can begin drying the mold.
Therefore we already know something about your third remediator and his or her claim.
Roof leaks will often lead to a small localized area of attic mold near where the leak is occurring.
Rot dry rot wet rot white rot brown rot is caused by wood decay fungi.
It is not necessary to remove all stains from wood.
How to remove mold from wood framing plywood sheathing tongue and groove subfloor or roof decking the object in cleaning mold from a wood surface is to remove all fungal material from the surface of the wood.
Rotted wood rafters in a roof are a serious issue.
Damage to rafter tails and to fascia and barge rafters.
That could indeed be and looks like a white fungus or mold growth on roof sheathing.
Excessive ceiling insulation pushed down into the roof edges can also cause condensation and mold growth because it frequently blocks off the eaves or soffit ventilation.
Working with active mold will only spread the fungus but you can.
Commonly what you can see of the rotted wood is only part of the problem it is what you cannot see under the surface of the wood that can be the main issue.
They require much higher levels of available water to grow.
Rafters sheathing joists attic side of fascia boards etc.